Middle East Turmoil on American Campuses.

Navigation: Main page

Author: Pipes, Daniel

Middle East Turmoil on American Campuses

Civilized Protests vs. Uncivilized Intolerance

Last week, two prominent Middle Easterners traveled to two North American campuses to deliver speeches mainly about the Arab-Israeli conflict. Both of them met protests. One succeeded in giving the speech and the other did not. Therein hangs a tale.

On Monday, Binyamin Netanyahu went to Concordia University in Montreal to explain why "there is no alternative to winning this war [on terrorism] without delay." But he never spoke at Concordia--indeed, he never made it onto the campus--because a thousand anti-Israel demonstrators staged a mini-riot with the intent of preventing Netanyahu from speaking; "Benjamin Netanyahu is coming to Montreal. Let's make it clear he's not welcome" read their signs.

The anti-Israel forces physically assaulted the would-be audience; a female professor of religion at Concordia recounted how some of them "aimed their punches at my breasts."

They smashed a plate-glass window and threw objects at the police inside. They hurled furniture at the police from a mezzanine.

As Toronto's Globe & Mail put it, "By lunchtime, the vestibule of Concordia's main downtown building was littered with paper, upturned chairs, broken furniture and the choking aftereffects of pepper spray."

The police said it could not assure Netanyahu's safety and cancelled the event. To which Wassim Moukahhal, an Arab leader at nearby McGill University, crowed: "The man is a war criminal. We don't want our city and our universities to be the harbor of such a war criminal."

Not was this the first time Netanyahu has been prevented from speaking on campus; in November 2000, "hundreds of raucous protesters" at the University of California-Berkeley likewise managed to cancel his appearance.

On Thursday, Hanan Ashrawi went to Colorado College in Colorado Springs to give a keynote speech at a symposium on "September 11: One Year Later."

Protestors to her speech noted that Ashrawi is smack on the side of America's enemies in the war on terrorism. For example, while the U.S. government formally designates Hamas a terrorist group, Ashrawi states she doesn't "think of Hamas as a terrorist group." Also, this former spokeswoman and colleague of Yasir Arafat considers Israelis living on the West Bank to be "legitimate ... targets of Palestinian resistance."

The many objections to Ashrawi's being honored at Colorado College centered on her obnoxious presence at an event dealing with the aftermath of September 11. Colorado's Governor Bill Owens spoke for many when he said, "it's outrageous to be bringing this woman who has done so much to divide the Middle East and has applauded terrorism." Both of the state's U.S. senators objected. Rudolph Giuliani added: "I wouldn't have invited her. Cancel it."

But she did speak, without any interference. The protests against Ashrawi were completely non-violent and included nothing more than scattered boos, hand-held signs, and a rebuttal following the speech (given by this writer).

These two parallel yet contrasting episodes point to several conclusions:

As the school year starts, both sides of the Arab-Israeli conflict are seeking to shift the terms of the debate. The pro-Israel side wants to delegitimize speakers who effectively call for the destruction of the Jewish state. The anti-Israel side wants to block speakers sympathetic to Israel.

• Both incidents point to profound problems in the university, and why Abigail Thernstrom calls it "an island of repression in a sea of freedom." In the Colorado case, the administration made the morally idiotic choice of honoring an apologist for terrorism. In the Concordia case, a weak-kneed response permitted thugs to inhibit free speech.

• These incidents also point to the differing faces of anti- and pro-Israel activism, with the former acceptably political and the latter crudely violent. The first resembles the restrained actions of the Israeli armed forces. The second represents a North American face of the suicide bombings. Or, to put them in their most elemental terms, we see here the contrast between the civilized nature of Israel and its friends versus the raw barbarism of Israel's enemies.

It promises to be a hot year politically at the campuses. How things turn out will depend on which form of activism prevails--the holding of pink sheets of paper with "I disagree" written on them or the throwing of chairs from balconies.

By Daniel Pipes

Mr. Pipes (www.DanielPipes.org) is director of the Middle East Forum and author of Militant Islam Reaches America.

Some items on this website are used by permission granted
in the Fair Use guidelines of the 1976 U.S. Copyright Act.
info [at] singlearticles.com
Powered by CommonSense

Life Didn't Pass Me By, It Stopped In for Gas.
The author comments on his life running an automobile repair business with his brother. To run a sma...

FLA. LAWMAKERS SEEK INFORMATION.
The article reports that two Florida state senators filed a suit on April 24, 2006, seeking informat...

RATES ON THE RISE.
The article discusses rising mortgage rates in the United States. Even though mortgage rates are ris...